GRAHAM, N.C. — Voters in several communities rejected incumbents aligned with 287(g) agreements, highlighting local pushback against partnerships that let sheriff’s offices help enforce federal immigration laws.
In North Carolina’s Alamance County, independent challenger Shannon Long defeated Republican Sheriff Terry Johnson after a campaign that, according to activists, voters and local officials, centered in part on immigration enforcement and how Latino residents were treated. Long, a pastor, business owner and former deputy, said trust with the county’s growing Latino community had frayed so much that his campaign van marked “sheriff” made some residents reluctant to speak with him.
Johnson is among a handful of sheriffs around the country who were unseated by opponents critical of cooperation with the Trump administration’s deportation efforts. While the number is small, the outcomes could signal difficulties ahead for other sheriffs tied to those policies and may complicate agreements that remain a pillar of federal enforcement.
Johnson was one of the earliest adopters of the 287(g) program, which allows local deputies to carry out certain federal immigration functions under U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Long pledged to scale back cooperation with ICE. The agency continues to rely on such partnerships to bolster arrests despite a substantial funding boost from Congress and the hiring of thousands of officers.
According to government data obtained by the Deportation Data Project and analyzed by the advocacy group fwd.us, more than 2,700 287(g) agreements are now in place with state and local agencies, up from 135 at the start of Trump’s second term. Predominantly in the South, the pacts have deputized over 29,000 local officers and accounted for more than 6,600 arrests in July, roughly 15% of ICE arrests.
The Associated Press reviewed about 250 sheriff elections this month in jurisdictions with 287(g) agreements and identified contests in Indiana, Maryland, North Carolina, Wisconsin and elsewhere where the program featured in a candidate’s defeat. Many incumbents ran unopposed. The issue is likely to resurface in two years when sheriffs in Florida, Texas and other states with large numbers of agreements are on the ballot.
287(g) agreements reshaping Alamance County politics
Alamance County, a longtime Republican stronghold of just under 200,000 residents between Greensboro and the Research Triangle, has become more competitive as its population diversified. Hispanic residents grew from 750 in 1990 to nearly 25,000 in 2020. A sheriff’s office spokesman confirmed the agency remains in the 287(g) program, though it ended an agreement last year to house ICE detainees.
Johnson, first elected in 2002, has been a prominent and polarizing figure. He has said he welcomes lawful immigrants and denied allegations that his office profiled minority residents, including claims raised in a Justice Department lawsuit more than a decade ago that concluded with a settlement.
School board member Seneca Rogers said the county’s “No Chance Alamance” moniker grew from perceptions of unjust policing and limited representation for Black and Latino residents. Johnson initially acknowledged immigration policy could have contributed to his defeat but later attributed the loss to his lengthy tenure and a difficult national climate for Republicans, particularly in North Carolina, where Democratic former Gov. Roy Cooper won a U.S. Senate seat by nearly 20 points. Johnson said he followed the law and focused on public safety.
Activists and longtime residents described reluctance among Latino, and to a degree Black, residents to engage with the sheriff’s office, saying non-white residents felt more likely to be stopped or detained after traffic encounters. Some were hesitant to call 911 or go to work, according to community organizer Leslie Arevalo.
Voter Renee Russell said cooperation with ICE projected Alamance as unwelcoming and welcomed new leadership. Local media reported Long will be the county’s first Black sheriff. Republican state Sen. Amy Galey, who represents the area, defended Johnson’s record on training and mental health initiatives. She did not think immigration dominated the race, but said aggressive ICE tactics elsewhere might have fueled broader concerns about law enforcement.
Candidates who backed ICE cooperation lost elsewhere
Frederick County, Maryland, long participated in the 287(g) program. Republican Sheriff Chuck Jenkins said the county detained and turned over 1,884 people to ICE since 2008, but that ended when Democratic Gov. Wes Moore signed a law this year banning such agreements. Jenkins, who maintained the program improved safety, said it likely cost him reelection. He lost to Democrat Karl Bickel, a retired U.S. Department of Justice employee who had previously lost to Jenkins four times and pledged not to cooperate with ICE.
“In general, people are fed up with the sheriff’s negativeness about immigrants,” said retired social worker Carol Antoniewicz, who promoted Bickel’s campaign materials and messages.
In Wisconsin’s Winnebago County, ICE’s arrest and detention of a schoolteacher weeks before Election Day triggered public backlash against perceived supporters of immigration enforcement, including a Republican candidate for an open sheriff’s seat.
“Any kind of perceived alignment definitely is considered a liability at this point,” said Molly Smiltneek, a local advocate and immigration lawyer who attended a vigil for the teacher.
Although the sheriff’s department was not involved in the arrest, its 287(g) agreement became a focal point in the race and aided Democrat Jason Rippl, who vowed to end it.
A newly elected sheriff seeks a better community partnership
Long, who previously served as a deputy in a neighboring North Carolina county, said he will enforce the law and hold offenders accountable, but he will not take part in the 287(g) program.
He has begun arranging meetings with Latino residents to rebuild trust. “I want them to see the sheriff’s office in the community, creating a partnership, letting them know that they have a voice. There’s no need to operate in fear,” he said.
Reporting by Sarah Rankin, Mikella Schuettler and David A. Lieb. Schuettler reported from Phoenix and Lieb from Jefferson City, Missouri. Additional reporting by Allen G. Breed in Graham. For broader context on how federal agencies and courts are approaching related issues, see Supreme Court denies review in DEI and gun-site cases.