HEAR Act unconstitutional is the central claim in a new filing by the Republic of Austria, the Albertina Museum, and the Leopold Museum Foundation, who on Friday responded to amicus briefs from two U.S. senators by reiterating that the updated Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act runs afoul of Article III of the Constitution and the Tenth Amendment.
The three defendants are fighting a lawsuit brought by Timothy Reif, a descendant of Fritz Grünbaum, a Jewish cabaret artist and collector killed in a death camp in 1941. Reif seeks the return of several Egon Schiele works he alleges were stolen by the Nazis when they seized Grünbaum’s collection. The defendants dispute the allegation, asserting the works stem from a cache exported from Austria by Grünbaum’s sister-in-law in the 1930s and later sold to a Swiss dealer in the 1950s.
Although they had previously raised constitutional objections in multiple motions, the defendants’ latest brief addresses new arguments advanced last month by the U.S. Department of Justice and by Senators Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut and John Cornyn of Texas, who cited additional precedent supporting the statute’s validity. Friday’s response takes up each of those cited cases.
While the filing states the defendants “respect the work of the Senators and the Government” and their efforts to address the harms of the Holocaust, it argues that in enacting the amended HEAR Act “Congress exceeded its constitutional bounds.” Blumenthal and Cornyn did not immediately comment.
HEAR Act unconstitutional claim centers on 2025 amendments
The dispute turns on amendments adopted in 2025 and signed by President Donald Trump last year. The original 2016 law was set to lapse in 2026, and the amendments extend it indefinitely. The changes also aimed to resolve issues that had derailed several prominent restitution suits on technical grounds, including varied state statutes of limitations.
The defendants contend the HEAR Act stops short of creating a comprehensive federal restitution regime, comparable to federal copyright law, and instead “delegates the substantive means to restitute Nazi-looted art to the states.” Courts must look to applicable state law, they argue, but the 2025 revisions remove certain technical defenses and thereby dictate outcomes in pending disputes.
On that basis, the filing argues the law violates the Tenth Amendment, which reserves to the states powers not granted to the federal government, and also infringes Article III’s separation of powers by constraining courts’ authority to decide cases and fashion remedies.
“By forbidding the federal courts from any longer considering these equitable defenses, Congress is intruding on the constitutional right and obligation of Article III courts to ‘decide’ such cases and controversies for themselves,” the response states.
One key change eliminates the equitable defense of laches, which can bar a claim when a plaintiff’s unreasonable delay causes prejudice to a current owner. The filing says the amendments prevent courts from factfinding on whether “inexcusable delay” resulted in loss of critical evidence and “unfair prejudice,” and adds that removing laches risks turning unprovable allegations of Nazi theft into presumptions favoring plaintiffs.
In a phone interview, defense attorney William L. Charron said the purpose of the filing was to respond directly to the additional constitutional arguments raised by the Justice Department and the two senators. He added that Reif v. Republic of Austria could be decided without reaching the constitutional question, but if courts conclude otherwise, the issue could ultimately reach the Supreme Court.
“We have given the Court a number of arguments and grounds to dismiss the case without having to rule upon these constitutional questions,” Charron said, adding that if the court addresses the HEAR Act’s constitutionality, he hopes it will seriously consider the positions laid out in the brief.
The case over Nazi-looted art comes amid ongoing debates about restitution and museum collections, an issue that has also surfaced around major institutions and exhibitions such as Art Basel Paris 2026. The defendants’ filing underscores how these disputes can hinge not only on provenance research but on the constitutional limits of congressional power.