The Stonehenge Altar Stone has long puzzled researchers, and a fresh analysis now indicates the six-ton sandstone slab likely did not come from northeast Scotland. The reassessment overturns a 2024 proposal that pointed to the Orcadian Basin, pushing scientists back into the field to determine where the enigmatic stone originated.
New findings on the Stonehenge Altar Stone
A study published this week in the Journal of the Geological Society compared the Stonehenge Altar Stone’s detailed geological signature with field samples collected across the proposed source area in Scotland’s Orcadian Basin. The team reports that the slab’s true origin remains unresolved, extending an ongoing effort to identify where the distinctive 16-foot stone began its journey.
“This is the most comprehensive geological investigation of the Altar Stone ever undertaken,” said lead author Duncan Pirrie, an emeritus geologist at the University of South Wales, in a statement.
He added that combining multiple analytical techniques produced the clearest picture yet of the stone’s composition and allowed the team to test leading origin theories. None of the examined locations matched the Stonehenge Altar Stone’s characteristics, he said, which narrows the search and helps target more promising areas.
Researchers combined direct examinations of the Stonehenge Altar Stone with analyses of archived samples to assess its sedimentology, geochemistry, and mineralogy. The work produced a detailed “geological fingerprint” of the slab.
Geologists then surveyed the Orcadian Basin for a match, a task described as daunting by study co-author Nick Pearce, an emeritus geochemist at Aberystwyth University. He noted that the region spans thousands of square kilometers, and the team gathered about 70 samples for laboratory testing.
Laboratory analyses failed to match any of those 70 samples to the Stonehenge Altar Stone, leading the researchers to conclude it is very unlikely the slab came from northeast Scotland.
Despite the setback, the team emphasized that excluding candidate areas advances the investigation. Pearce said ruling out potential sources is as important as identifying new ones, and that tracing the stone’s origin could illuminate its transport to Salisbury Plain thousands of years ago.
Stonehenge was built in phases between 3000 B.C.E. and 1520 B.C.E. The large sarsen stones came from Marlborough Downs in southern England, while smaller bluestones were brought roughly 140 miles from the Preseli Hills in southwest Wales.
The Preseli Hills were long considered the likely source of the Stonehenge Altar Stone, which lies flat and partially buried beneath the fallen upright and lintel of the monument’s largest trilithon. The 2024 Scottish hypothesis extended that range to more than 400 miles, raising questions about whether Neolithic builders moved the slab overland or by water.
Altar Stone origins and enduring name
In 1620, landscape architect Inigo Jones proposed that the partially buried stone near the monument’s center served as an altar, a name that has endured ever since.
Earlier this year, glaciologists modeled past ice sheets to test whether glaciers could have carried the stone during the last Ice Age. They found that Scottish boulders could have been pushed near Dogger Bank in the North Sea, but human intervention would still have been required thousands of years before Stonehenge’s construction.
With northeast Scotland and southern Britain both considered unlikely sources, the search for the Stonehenge Altar Stone now shifts to northern England, other parts of Scotland, or possibly Ireland.
Identifying the original quarry could yield insights into the people who transported the stone. Archaeologist Mike Pitts, who was not involved in the study, said determining the source would help place the Altar Stone in the world of its movers and reveal precisely where its journey began.
For more reporting on how scientific discoveries reshape our understanding of the natural world, read how crows make decisions fast, about twice as quick as humans.