Supreme Court order list rejects over 200 petitions

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp

The Supreme Court order list released Monday documented denials of review in more than 200 cases, including disputes linked to the aftermath of George Floyd’s murder in Minneapolis, a challenge by the family of baseball legend Roberto Clemente, and a petition filed by actor Randy Quaid and his wife.

From the same Nov. 6 conference, the court on Friday granted review in a separate case testing when a bankruptcy court may decline to enforce an agreement to arbitrate disputes.

Supreme Court order list includes Minneapolis takings case

One denied petition stemmed from Minneapolis, where a group of businesses operating at the intersection where Floyd was killed challenged the city’s response following his death. According to their filing, the city installed concrete barricades that blocked vehicles and pedestrians from the intersection and withdrew police protection. The businesses said the barricades remained for more than a year, led to substantial economic losses, and coincided with increased violent crime.

The businesses sued in state court, alleging violations of the federal Takings Clause and comparable protections under the Minnesota Constitution for interfering with their operations without compensation. A district court and the Minnesota Court of Appeals rejected the claims, and the Minnesota Supreme Court refused review. The businesses then sought to revive the case at the U.S. Supreme Court, which on Monday declined without comment.

Clemente family dispute over image rights

A separate petition by Roberto Clemente’s adult sons and related companies also invoked the Takings Clause. They challenged Puerto Rico’s use of Clemente’s image on license plates and tags, an initiative that the petition said generated $15 million for Puerto Rico and drew public resentment toward the family over a related fee. The lawsuit sought to block future use of Clemente’s image and to recover damages.

Earlier this year, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 1st Circuit halted the takings claim, emphasizing that the provision, together with federal trademark law, is aimed at remedying the taking of property for public use without just compensation, not at protecting legacies. In June, the Clemente family asked the justices to consider whether the Takings Clause can apply to intangible property. After considering the petition at three consecutive conferences, the court denied review on Monday.

Randy Quaid petition on access to law enforcement records

The petition filed by Randy Quaid and Evgenia Quaid concerned alleged access to restricted law enforcement databases that include criminal history, warrant status, and booking records. Their filing asserted that an employee of the Santa Barbara Sheriff’s Department sent restricted material about the couple to an assistant district attorney, who then shared it with a private attorney, without any subpoena, discovery request, court order, or law enforcement purpose. They argued the disclosures violated privacy laws.

A federal district court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit rejected the Quaids’ claims, holding they were barred by the litigation privilege, which shields communications made in the course of judicial proceedings. The Supreme Court declined to review the case.

Requests for government views and remands

The justices asked the U.S. solicitor general to provide the government’s views in AstraZeneca UK Ltd. v. Atchley. The case concerns whether U.S. terrorism victims may sue 21 large pharmaceutical and medical device companies under the Antiterrorism Act for allegedly aiding and abetting terrorists in Iraq.

The court also sent Roybal v. Griffith, a challenge by a transgender female inmate to El Paso County, Colorado jail policies on the treatment of transgender inmates, back to the lower court for reconsideration in light of West Virginia v. B.P.J. and United States v. Skrmetti.

In B.P.J., decided in June, the court held that state laws barring transgender female athletes from women’s and girls’ teams do not violate a federal civil rights statute or the Equal Protection Clause. In Skrmetti last year, the court upheld a Tennessee law restricting certain medical treatments for transgender minors, concluding the law was not subject to heightened scrutiny under the Equal Protection Clause.

Solicitor general to argue in three December cases

The court granted the solicitor general’s requests to participate in three arguments during the December sitting:

  • Jouppi v. Alaska (Dec. 1): Whether forfeiture of a $95,000 airplane, based on a passenger transporting beer into a dry Alaska village, violates the Eighth Amendment’s Excessive Fines Clause.
  • Viramontes v. Cook County, consolidated with Grant v. Higgins (Dec. 2): Whether bans on AR-15s and other semiautomatic rifles violate the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms.
  • International Partners for Ethical Care v. Ferguson (Dec. 7): Whether parents have standing to challenge state laws that, among other provisions, allow runaway minors seeking gender-transition services to be referred without parental notice or consent.
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp