Supreme Court denies review in DEI and gun-site cases

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp

The Supreme Court denies review in several closely watched matters, turning away petitions that involved federal research funding tied to diversity, equity, and inclusion policies, a California medical education rule on implicit bias, and a challenge to Maryland’s restrictions on carrying firearms in designated sensitive places. The justices also requested the U.S. solicitor general’s views in terrorism-related lawsuits against the Taliban. The actions were listed in orders from the Court’s private conference on Friday and released Monday morning.

Separately, the Court announced after Friday’s conference that it had added two cases to the current term’s argument calendar: Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, concerning whether the Trump administration can suspend access to asylum at the U.S.-Mexico border, and Robinhood Markets, Inc. v. Sodha, addressing whether a company violated federal securities laws by omitting certain interim financial data in its IPO disclosures.

Research funding and DEI

In Trump v. Thakur, University of California faculty and researchers challenged grant terminations that followed executive orders issued early in President Donald Trump’s second term, which targeted reductions in government spending and the withdrawal of support from DEI initiatives. Agencies curtailed grants for projects they linked to disfavored topics, prompting lawsuits from states, universities, and individual scholars.

The UC plaintiffs sought relief on behalf of a class of similarly situated scholars, alleging violations of the First Amendment, due process, and administrative law. In June 2025, a federal district court in California preliminarily ordered reinstatement of grants for two overlapping classes: researchers who received standardized termination notices lacking grant-specific reasons, and those whose funding was cut due to DEI-related directives. The court found the first category likely arbitrary and capricious under administrative law, and the second likely to violate free speech protections.

After the Ninth Circuit initially declined to stay the order, the Supreme Court, in an interim matter styled National Institutes of Health v. American Public Health Association, paused a separate Massachusetts ruling that would have required NIH to pay grants it sought to terminate. Citing limits on lower courts’ authority to enforce obligations to pay money on research grants, the Ninth Circuit later amended its stance and, in May 2026, reversed the district court as to the form-letter class, concluding the lower court likely lacked jurisdiction to order reinstatement.

The Ninth Circuit, however, affirmed the injunction for the class claiming First Amendment violations tied to DEI-based terminations. The panel reasoned that while the government may structure subsidy programs, it may not discriminate among speakers within an established program to suppress disfavored viewpoints.

In August, the administration urged the Supreme Court to review that portion of the ruling, arguing it conflicted with precedent and intruded on executive spending priorities. The solicitor general asserted the First Amendment does not compel continued funding of projects deemed not in the public interest. The researchers countered there was no circuit split and emphasized the attempt to cut off already approved, merit-based awards based on perceived viewpoints. On Monday, the Court declined to hear the case without comment.

DEI and continuing education for doctors

In Khatibi v. Yip, California ophthalmologist Dr. Azadeh Khatibi and other physicians challenged a Medical Board requirement that state-approved continuing medical education courses include content on understanding implicit bias. A federal district judge dismissed the suit, concluding the courses qualified as government speech and were not subject to the First Amendment’s free speech clause. The Ninth Circuit affirmed.

The petitioners argued that CME instructors develop their own original content without state drafting, editing, topic assignment, or meaningful oversight, warning that the ruling would allow states to conscript private professionals into advancing contested ideologies in licensure-related settings. The Medical Board urged denial, describing the dispute as narrow and emphasizing that instructors must only meet conditions to receive state-approved CME credit.

The Supreme Court denied review. Justice Neil Gorsuch would have granted the petition. Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented from the denial, writing that the Ninth Circuit’s approach misunderstands precedent and the Constitution, and that First Amendment protections do not yield simply because a state heavily regulates speech.

The Second Amendment and sensitive places

The Court also declined to review Novotny v. Moore, which challenged Maryland laws barring firearms in locations including government buildings, school grounds, public transit, state parks, stadiums, and establishments that sell alcohol. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit upheld the restrictions under the Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision, which recognized limits on public carry in sensitive places.

The petitioners argued the sensitive-places exception is narrow and that the constitutionality of such location-based bans is a critical post-Bruen question. Maryland cited broad consensus among lower courts and a historical tradition of place-specific firearm regulations consistent with the state’s laws.

Justice Thomas issued a statement expressing skepticism that each restriction aligns with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation in sensitive places. He agreed with the denial because the breadth of the challenge would complicate review, adding that a more focused case could be appropriate to define the scope of state authority.

Other notable denials

The justices declined to hear a range of additional cases. In Strickland v. Moritz, a former federal public defender in North Carolina challenged the adequacy of the federal judiciary’s internal system for handling sexual harassment and employment discrimination claims. In Gays Against Groomers v. Garcia, the Tenth Circuit rejected a challenge to the Colorado General Assembly’s rules against misgendering or using former names for transgender or nonbinary people during committee hearings, holding such decorum rules fall within legitimate legislative activity and are shielded by legislative immunity.

In Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, the Court left in place a Tenth Circuit decision upholding the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas’s refusal to grant the Wyoming institution a master account. The appellate court held that federal law gives the Federal Reserve discretion to deny account requests even when the applicant is otherwise eligible, and the Fed had cited heightened risk from Custodia’s crypto-focused business model as inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices.

Government’s views sought in terrorism cases

The Court invited the solicitor general to submit the administration’s views in three cases brought by victims of the 1998 U.S. embassy bombings in Kenya and Tanzania and by victims of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. The petitions relate to efforts to reach funds of Afghanistan’s central bank held at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and raise questions about determining when an entity is a foreign state for purposes of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act and the interpretation of the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act regarding recovery from seized or frozen assets.

The United States has not recognized the Taliban as Afghanistan’s government, and the Taliban did not respond to the petitions. A friend-of-the-court brief from the head of Afghanistan’s permanent mission to the United Nations urged denial, supporting compensation for victims but opposing recovery from Afghan state assets on the grounds that the Afghan people bear no liability for the Taliban’s crimes. Justice Elena Kagan did not participate in the decision to seek the government’s input in two of the three matters, noting her recusal based on prior government service. No deadline was set for the solicitor general’s briefs.

The orders came as the Court continued to manage a heavy docket of appeals, following earlier actions in which a Supreme Court order list rejected over 200 petitions in a single day. The latest moves underscore the justices’ preference to let several contentious lower court rulings stand while inviting further input before wading into complex terrorism-related disputes.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp