Michigan judge DUI proceedings ended Monday with a conviction for impaired driving, but a court rejected a separate charge alleging a high blood alcohol concentration.
Warren 37th District Court Chief Judge John M. Chmura, 63, was found guilty of intoxication after his Ford Fusion struck a parked public transit bus displaying hazard lights on March 25, according to court findings. The bus driver, who was inside the vehicle awaiting the next route, was not injured.
Michigan judge DUI case narrowed by court
Novi 52nd District Court Judge David Law ruled that prosecutors had not proven beyond a reasonable doubt that Chmura’s blood alcohol content was 0.17 or higher, the level tied to the state’s more serious high BAC offense. Judge Law said Chmura’s judgment was impaired but questioned the blood alcohol concentration at the time of the crash.
“This court may think it knows the answer to whether or not this was a high BAC case. But thinking it knows is not enough. It needs to be proven beyond a reasonable doubt,” Law said.
Sterling Heights Police Officer Jonathan Journeau testified that Chmura smelled of alcohol, had slurred speech, and struggled to maintain balance. Defense lawyer David J. Kramer of the David J. Kramer Law Firm argued the state could not meet the higher charge because investigators did not establish when Chmura consumed his last drink, a factor he said was critical to determining BAC at the moment of impact.
The ruling leaves Chmura convicted of impaired driving while dismissing the allegation that he drove with a high BAC. The outcome contrasts with higher-profile disciplinary matters, such as when Larry Klayman was disbarred by the Supreme Court after a D.C. case.