South Carolina road rage shooting leads to new murder charges

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp

Two men initially cleared in a South Carolina road rage shooting three years ago now face murder charges after the victim’s family pushed for a new review and uncovered evidence suggesting officers influenced the investigation, according to court filings and officials.

Two Horry County officers have also been indicted on obstruction of justice and misconduct in office charges tied to the probe into the September 2023 killing of Scott Spivey. The latest charges followed an independent reassessment of the case sought by Spivey’s relatives after prosecutors first declined to charge the shooters, identified as Weldon Boyd and Kenneth Williams. The family then filed a civil lawsuit.

Family finds evidence after shooters are initially cleared in South Carolina road rage shooting

The family obtained recordings of Boyd’s phone calls in which he boasted about the shooting and asked a police officer friend to intervene, according to materials produced in the civil case. Body camera footage also captured another officer passing a handwritten note to the men on the day of the shooting that read, “act like a victim camera.”

Authorities said the confrontation began when Boyd and Williams chased Spivey for several miles after Spivey pulled a gun during a road rage incident. Investigators said both pickups reached speeds topping 100 mph before Spivey turned onto a side road, got out with a gun, and told the men to stop following him. The men then fired through their truck’s windshield, striking Spivey in the right side of his back near his armpit, investigators said.

The local prosecutor referred the case to the South Carolina Attorney General’s Office after Boyd posted a public message a week after the shooting thanking police and prosecutors for their work. Seven months later, the Attorney General’s Office declined to prosecute Boyd and Williams, finding they were threatened and acted lawfully under the state’s stand your ground law.

Ruling leads to civil suit and more information

The civil action unearthed Boyd’s recorded calls. In them, he discussed with Williams the idea of getting teardrop tattoos because they had killed a man, described Spivey as terrified during the chase after realizing he could drive faster, and said of the shooting, “I know it’s (expletive) up to say, but I had a (expletive) blast.”

Following the new disclosures, the officers were fired and the Attorney General’s Office asked Spartanburg prosecutor Barry Barnette to reexamine the matter. He convened another grand jury, which returned indictments on Thursday.

Attorneys for all four defendants argued that publicity has tainted the proceedings and maintained their clients’ innocence. Boyd’s lawyer, Shaun Kent, said the criminal case should be dismissed in part because prosecutors relied on evidence obtained through the civil lawsuit, citing a tactic that previously led to the dismissal of charges against Bill Cosby. Kent also noted initial findings that Spivey had alcohol in his system, saying in court, “He was intoxicated. He had a firearm. He was pointing it at other individuals.”

Officers charged for conduct during investigation

A grand jury indicted Boyd and Williams on murder charges. Former Horry County Deputy Chief Brandon Strickland and Sgt. Damon Vescovi were charged with misconduct in office and obstruction of justice.

According to Boyd’s recorded calls, he phoned Strickland multiple times at the scene and afterward, and Strickland said he had spoken with investigators and prosecutors. Strickland’s attorney told the court at a bond hearing that while the comments may have been inappropriate, there is no proof he influenced the investigation.

Vescovi passed along the note about the camera. His lawyer said he exercised poor judgment but believed at the time that Boyd and Williams were victims of a road rage incident.

At Thursday’s hearing, Jennifer Spivey, who reviewed case materials until she found the note and heard Boyd’s calls, urged the judge to ensure accountability. “Scott tried desperately to escape the violence that ultimately took his life,” she said.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp